LookItAllUp logoLookItAllUp
What Reviewers Love

What Reviewers Love: Craft Supply Best Sellers, Decoded

We sifted through customer feedback on today's top-selling craft supplies to show what buyers consistently praise, what frustrates them, and which picks earn their spot.

Updated November 11, 2026 10 picks from Amazon Best Sellers

As an Amazon Associate, LookItAllUp earns from qualifying purchases.

If you're stocking up for school projects, holiday makes or a weekend refinishing job, this guide sorts the craft best sellers by what buyers actually say about them. The headline: Rust-Oleum's clear gloss spray earns the warmest praise for its shiny, lasting finish, while Elmer's purple glue sticks are the crowd favourite for kids. With mid-November here, P&J's six-scent Christmas oil set is the seasonal standout.

Our top picks

Best overall

Buyers repeatedly call it the best spray paint they've used, citing a glossy finish that stays shiny on almost any surface.

See it on Amazon
Best for kids

The purple-to-clear formula shows children exactly where they've glued and is non-toxic and washable.

See it on Amazon
Best seasonal pick

Six festive scents, with gingerbread and cinnamon reviewer favourites, make it ideal for Christmas candles and soaps.

See it on Amazon

Compare the picks

  1. Reviewers love
    Shiny finish that lasts
    Common complaint
    Occasional faulty nozzle
    Best for
    Furniture and décor refreshes
  2. Reviewers love
    See-where-you-glue purple colour
    Common complaint
    Not sticky enough for some
    Best for
    Kids and classrooms
  3. Reviewers love
    Clear, easy, great value
    Common complaint
    Thin sheets for some
    Best for
    Teachers laminating in bulk
  4. Reviewers love
    Prints cleanly, bright white
    Common complaint
    Flimsy or damaged sheets
    Best for
    Printed cards and covers
  5. Reviewers love
    Huge bottle lasts many batches
    Common complaint
    Scent weaker than expected
    Best for
    Soap and body-butter makers
  6. Reviewers love
    Easy on, easy off
    Common complaint
    Some strips fall quickly
    Best for
    Renters and dorm rooms
  7. Reviewers love
    Gingerbread and cinnamon scents
    Common complaint
    Value divides buyers
    Best for
    Christmas candles and soaps
  8. Reviewers love
    Beautiful glossy topcoat
    Common complaint
    Uneven coverage reports
    Best for
    Sealing outdoor projects
  9. Reviewers love
    No glue-stick mess
    Common complaint
    Runs out fast
    Best for
    Scrapbooking and card layers
  10. Reviewers love
    Softer-feeling skin
    Common complaint
    Bottle less full than expected
    Best for
    DIY skincare blends
1Rust-Oleum Painter's Touch 2X Ultra Cover Spray Paint, Gloss Clear

Most praised finish overall#1 best seller

Rust-Oleum 2X Clear Gloss Spray

Rust-Oleum Painter's Touch 2X Ultra Cover Spray Paint, Gloss Clear

Plenty of buyers call this the best spray paint they've used, and the reason comes up again and again: a beautiful glossy finish that stays shiny. Reviewers also highlight good coverage and how easy it is to use, with many feeling it is well worth the money.

The oil-based formula is made for wood, plastic, metal, plaster, masonry and unglazed ceramic, dries to the touch in 20 minutes and covers up to 12 sq. ft. per can. The any-angle spray and wider comfort tip suit longer sessions. The one recurring gripe is a nozzle that some say broke almost immediately on their first can.

What we like

  • Glossy finish reviewers say stays shiny
  • Works on wood, metal, plastic and more
  • Dries to the touch in 20 minutes
  • Comfort tip and any-angle spraying

Keep in mind

  • Some report a nozzle failing early
  • Covers up to 12 sq. ft. per can, so bigger jobs need several

Best for: DIYers who want a durable, shiny clear coat on furniture, décor or crafts across many surface types.

2Elmer's Disappearing Purple School Glue Sticks, Washable, 22g, 3 Count

Best for kids and classrooms#2 best seller

Elmer's Disappearing Purple Glue Sticks

Elmer's Disappearing Purple School Glue Sticks, Washable, 22g, 3 Count

Parents and teachers love the simple trick here: the glue goes on purple so you can see where it's been applied, then dries clear. Reviewers say it's easy for children and adults alike and holds up through a full day of school use.

It's acid-free, photo safe, non-toxic and washable, and bonds to paper, cardboard, foam board and display board. The split opinion is on grip: many find it plenty strong for paper, while others say it isn't very sticky for heavier materials.

What we like

  • Purple colour shows coverage, dries clear
  • Non-toxic, washable and acid-free
  • Easy for young kids to use

Keep in mind

  • Some buyers find the hold weak
  • Best limited to paper and light board

Best for: Families and classrooms that want a mess-aware, kid-friendly glue for paper and poster projects.

3Amazon Basics Clear Thermal Laminating Sheets for Documents and Photos, 9 x 11.5-Inch, 2.8 mil, 200-Pack

Best value for teachers#3 best seller

Amazon Basics Laminating Sheets, 200-Pack

Amazon Basics Clear Thermal Laminating Sheets for Documents and Photos, 9 x 11.5-Inch, 2.8 mil, 200-Pack

Teachers are a big part of this fan base, with buyers describing these as ideal for making reading and math centers. Reviewers praise the crystal-clear look, the ease of use and the sheer value of a 200-sheet pack.

The 2.8 mil sheets measure 9 x 11.5 inches and are designed for all leading thermal laminators, and you can trim them for custom sizes. Opinions differ on thickness, with some calling them sturdy enough and others finding them very thin, and a few report adhesion problems.

What we like

  • 200 sheets per pack
  • Crystal-clear finish reviewers praise
  • Works with leading thermal laminators

Keep in mind

  • Some find the 2.8 mil sheets thin
  • Occasional adhesion complaints

Best for: Teachers and parents laminating lots of worksheets, recipes or photos on a thermal laminator.

4Amazon Basics Cardstock Paper, 8.5" x 11", 65 lb/176 gsm, 96 Bright White, 250 Sheets

Best for printable card projects#4 best seller

Amazon Basics White Cardstock, 250 Sheets

Amazon Basics Cardstock Paper, 8.5" x 11", 65 lb/176 gsm, 96 Bright White, 250 Sheets

Buyers say this cardstock feeds well through home printers, laser printers included, and like its bright white shade and pleasing weight. It turns up in card making, school projects and church work.

At 65 lb / 176 gsm and 96 brightness, it's sturdier than copy paper and FSC certified. Feedback is mixed on heft, though: some praise its thickness while others find it flimsy, and a few mention receiving damaged pages.

What we like

  • Prints well, including on laser printers
  • Bright 96 white for crisp results
  • 250 sheets per pack
  • FSC certified

Keep in mind

  • Some find it thinner than expected
  • Reports of damaged sheets on arrival

Best for: Home crafters and church or school volunteers printing cards, covers and booklets in bulk.

5Handcraft Blends Lavender Essential Oil - Huge 4 Fl Oz

Best big bottle for DIY#5 best seller

Handcraft Blends Lavender Oil, 4 oz

Handcraft Blends Lavender Essential Oil - Huge 4 Fl Oz

The generous 4 oz size is what reviewers mention most, with one buyer saying a single bottle lasted through about 50 batches of body butter. Others use it in ultrasonic diffusers and moisturizers and say it helps them unwind.

It comes in an amber glass bottle with a glass dropper and is pitched at soap making, skincare and massage. Scent strength is where opinions divide: some find it lovely, others say it's weaker and less concentrated than they expected.

What we like

  • Large bottle for repeat batches
  • Amber glass with glass dropper
  • Versatile for soap, skincare and diffusers

Keep in mind

  • Some find the scent weak
  • Not as concentrated as some expected

Best for: Soap and body-butter makers who go through lavender oil quickly and value quantity.

6Command 15 & 10 lb Assorted Picture Hanging Strips, 28 Pairs, SIOC

Best for renters and dorms#6 best seller

Command Picture Hanging Strips, 28 Pairs

Command 15 & 10 lb Assorted Picture Hanging Strips, 28 Pairs, SIOC

Reviewers love how easy these are to apply and remove, making them a go-to for hanging pictures without nails. The pack mixes 12 pairs of 10 lb medium strips and 16 pairs of 15 lb large strips.

The complaints are about staying power: while many say frames stay put, others report strips falling off within days. Following the instructions matters here, including cleaning with rubbing alcohol, waiting seven days after painting and avoiding wallpaper.

What we like

  • No nails or tools needed
  • Clean removal by pulling straight down
  • Mixed sizes for different frames

Keep in mind

  • Some report strips falling within days
  • Value opinions are split

Best for: Renters and students hanging lightweight frames on smooth painted walls without leaving holes.

7P&J Trading Scented Oils Christmas Set of 6 for Home, Diffusers

Best for holiday makes#7 best seller

P&J Christmas Scented Oils, Set of 6

P&J Trading Scented Oils Christmas Set of 6 for Home, Diffusers

Buyers adore the festive scents, singling out gingerbread, cinnamon and candy cane as favourites, and say they work well in handmade candles and soaps. One reviewer found a few drops kept a diffuser going all day.

The set includes six 10ml bottles: Christmas Wreath, Mistletoe, Candy Cane, Gingerbread, Cinnamon and Cranberry, formulated to IFRA guidelines. The only real split is on value, with some feeling it's worth the money and others not.

What we like

  • Six distinct festive scents
  • Reviewers say a few drops last
  • Works in candles, soaps and diffusers

Keep in mind

  • Mixed opinions on value
  • 10ml bottles go quickly in candle making

Best for: Holiday crafters making Christmas candles, soaps or gifts who want variety in one box.

8Krylon K05515007 COLORmaxx Acrylic Clear Finish for Indoor/Outdoor Use, Gloss Crystal Clear , 11 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Best clear coat for outdoor pieces#8 best seller

Krylon COLORmaxx Gloss Clear Coat

Krylon K05515007 COLORmaxx Acrylic Clear Finish for Indoor/Outdoor Use, Gloss Crystal Clear , 11 Ounce (Pack of 1)

Fans praise the beautiful glossy finish and overall quality, with one using it successfully on outdoor glider furniture frames. Krylon describes it as non-yellowing and suitable for wood, metal, wicker, most plastics, glass, fabric and paper.

It dries to the touch in 20 minutes or less and covers up to 15-20 sq. ft. per can. Reviews are mixed on coverage, with some noting uneven results, and on value. Best results come at 55 to 75 degrees with humidity under 60%.

What we like

  • Glossy, non-yellowing finish
  • Indoor and outdoor use
  • Covers up to 15-20 sq. ft.

Keep in mind

  • Some report uneven coverage
  • Sensitive to temperature and humidity

Best for: Crafters sealing projects, including outdoor furniture, who want a glossy clear topcoat.

9Secopad Scrapbook Tape, Glue Tape for Crafts, 4 Pack, Light-Colored Shell

Best mess-free paper adhesive#9 best seller

Secopad Scrapbook Glue Tape, 4 Pack

Secopad Scrapbook Tape, Glue Tape for Crafts, 4 Pack, Light-Colored Shell

Scrapbookers like that this runner skips the mess of glue sticks and needs no drying time. Reviewers call it good quality and well suited to paper projects, and you can reposition if you act quickly.

The drawbacks are consistent: grip is mixed, and many feel each dispenser runs out quickly and holds less tape than expected. The brand notes cold temperatures can weaken stickiness, so it's best used indoors where it's warm.

What we like

  • No mess and no drying wait
  • Repositionable if fixed quickly
  • Easy for kids and adults

Keep in mind

  • Runs out faster than expected
  • Mixed reports on stickiness

Best for: Scrapbookers and card makers who want a clean, fast adhesive for light paper layers.

10100% Pure Frankincense Essential Oil for Skin & Diffuser - 4 Fl Oz

Best for skincare blends#10 best seller

Pure Frankincense Essential Oil, 4 oz

100% Pure Frankincense Essential Oil for Skin & Diffuser - 4 Fl Oz

Reviewers mention using this in skincare blends and say their skin feels softer and smoother, with one saying their face had never looked better. Others report it helps them relax and sleep and use it diluted for sore knees and headaches, though these are personal experiences rather than proven effects.

The brand describes it as Boswellia serrata with a precision Euro dropper and advises always diluting before topical use. Scent reactions split, with the brand itself noting a bold earthy-resinous aroma, and several buyers were disappointed that the bottle seemed smaller or less full than expected.

What we like

  • Reviewers report softer, smoother skin
  • Useful in candles, soaps and diffusers
  • Precision Euro dropper

Keep in mind

  • Bottle fill disappointed some buyers
  • Bold scent isn't for everyone
  • Mixed views on authenticity

Best for: DIY skincare and soap makers who enjoy a strong, resinous frankincense note.

How we chose these

We started from the top 10 products on Amazon's Best Seller list for Craft Supplies (as of November 8, 2026) and wrote this What Reviewers Love guide, with AI assistance, from their product details and what customers say in their reviews. We haven't tested these products ourselves, and no product or position is paid for. Rankings and availability change, so check Amazon for the latest details.

The verdict

For sheer enthusiasm across buyers, Rust-Oleum's Painter's Touch 2X clear gloss is our top pick: reviewers praise its shiny, lasting finish, easy application and versatility on everything from wood to metal, with an occasional faulty nozzle as the main gripe. Grab Elmer's purple glue sticks if kids are doing the crafting, and with the holidays approaching, the P&J Christmas oil set is the one buyers reach for to make homemade candles and soaps feel festive.

Our top pick: Rust-Oleum 2X Clear Gloss Spray

Check today's price on Amazon