As an Amazon Associate, LookItAllUp earns from qualifying purchases.
This guide is for parents shopping for a pretend play gift on a budget or with a specific age in mind. Reviewers consistently say the best picks keep kids busy for hours, while the biggest gaps are in durability, size and how well small parts hold up. The short version: the wooden ice cream counter earns the most praise for lasting, and the unicorn jewelry box is the easiest win for younger children.
What reviewers keep praising
Hours of pretend play
Buyers repeatedly say the toy-making, learning and role-play sets keep kids busy for long stretches. The VTech toolbox, ice cream counter, doctor kit and purse set come up most often for this.
Cute designs kids notice
Unicorn and pink styling stands out with buyers. The musical unicorn box, unicorn makeup kit and doctor kit with a puppy are called adorable by reviewers.
Easy to give as a gift
Many buyers mention these as birthday or holiday gifts. The ice cream counter, hair stamper kit and unicorn music box are the clearest examples.
Durability and size vary
Build quality and size get mixed reports. The ice cream counter earns praise for sturdiness, while the doctor kit, hair gems and makeup kits get more mixed notes on breakage, falling pieces or small size.
Our top picks
Reviewers say a 3-year-old can wind the music knob and the box is sized for small hands.
See it on AmazonBuyers say this unicorn makeup kit offers nice quality for the price and is easy to clean.
See it on AmazonSeveral reviewers say the wooden counter is sturdy enough for years of play.
See it on Amazon
Best for hair-play fans#1 best seller
Hair Gem Stamper Kit
Hair Gem Stamper Kit, Bling Hair Jewels for Girls Toys, Hair Styling Tool with Reusable Shining Diamonds, Birthday Gifts Toys for Girls Ages 3 4 5 6 8-12 (Red Pink)
This kit lets girls press reusable gems into their hair to create their own looks. Reviewers like that it adds instant sparkle without pulling, and that the reusable diamonds make it a go-to for daily restyling. The kit includes a stamper tool and 24 gems in assorted styles, according to the listing.
The main complaint is that some gems fall off easily, so buyers who want a secure hold should plan on touch-ups. Opinions on value are split, with some calling it worth the price and others finding it overpriced.
What we like
- Reusable gems can be used again and again
- Adds sparkle without tugging the hair
- Good gift for kids who enjoy fashion and crafts
Keep in mind
- Some gems fall off easily
- Value for money receives mixed reviews
Best for: Girls who love experimenting with hairstyles and making DIY hair accessories.

Best for first-time makeup fans#2 best seller
58 Pcs Kids Makeup Toys Kit
58 Pcs Kids Makeup Toys Kit for Girls, Real Washable Make Up Set
This large kit packs in eye shadows, blushes, lip glosses, brushes and nail polish, plus a tutorial booklet and a carrying case. Reviewers describe it as a great little set for children just starting out with makeup, and one noted it matches the pictures.
The two repeat complaints are size and fit. Several buyers found it smaller than expected, and the top and drawers are hard to open and close, which makes the case less convenient to use.
What we like
- Wide range of pieces in one set
- Carrying case keeps everything together
- Matches pictures, according to one buyer
Keep in mind
- Smaller than expected
- Top and drawers are hard to open and close
Best for: Young children who want a full makeup set to play with at home.

Best for hands-on learning#3 best seller
VTech Drill and Learn Toolbox
The toolbox includes a working toy drill, hammer, wrench, nails and screws, plus an electronic fix-it tray. Buyers say it keeps toddlers engaged for long stretches and helps build hand coordination and problem-solving skills. The light-up buttons and songs add to the appeal.
Functionality is the sticking point. Some reviewers say the drill is hard to operate, and others report it does not work properly at all. The toy takes 2 AA batteries, and the listing says new ones are recommended for regular use.
What we like
- Keeps toddlers busy for hours
- Builds motor skills and problem-solving
- Light-up buttons and songs add play value
Keep in mind
- Drill is difficult to operate for some
- Reports of it not working properly
Best for: Toddlers aged 2 to 5 who love pretend repairs and turning gears.

Most durable pick in the set#4 best seller
Melissa & Doug Ice Cream Counter
Melissa & Doug Wooden Scoop & Serve Ice Cream Counter, Pretend Play Store, 28 Toy Food & Play Kitchen Accessories, Preschool Toys for Girls & Boys 3+
This 28-piece wooden set includes scoops, toppings, cones, a menu card and play money, all stored in a countertop that doubles as a box. Customers call it one of the best pretend play toys they have bought, and many mention it as a favorite holiday gift that holds toddlers' attention for hours.
Reviewers stand out for durability. Several say the counter is sturdy enough to last through years of play, which is rare at this price point. The sets are simple, open-ended and screen-free, so the fun comes from the child's own story.
What we like
- Sturdy enough for years of use
- Keeps toddlers entertained for hours
- Countertop doubles as storage
Keep in mind
- Limited to pretend ice cream play
Best for: Families who want a long-lasting kitchen-style pretend play gift for ages 3 and up.

Best for doctor role-play#7 best seller
Meland Doctor Kit with Puppy
Meland Doctor Kit with Puppy for Girls, Pretend Play Toy Gift for Ages 3–6
The kit includes a plush puppy, a doctor coat and hat, a stethoscope, thermometer, otoscope and many other tools. Buyers say it is super cute and offers a big variety of supplies that keep children entertained. Reviewers feel it suits 4-year-olds especially well.
Build quality is where opinions split. Some describe it as well made and durable, while others call it cheap and say pieces break easily. Value is also divided, with some calling it good for the price and others finding it overpriced.
What we like
- Large variety of medical play pieces
- Plush puppy adds a cuddly extra
- Suits 4-year-olds well, according to reviewers
Keep in mind
- Some pieces break easily
- Value for money is divided
Best for: Girls aged 3 to 6 who enjoy doctor and nurse pretend play with a pet patient.

Best for grown-up role-play#8 best seller
Play Purse with Watch and Phone
Play Purse with Watch, Phone, Pretend Play Toys for Girls Ages 3-8
This set packs a wallet, sunglasses, car keys, play money and cards, a toy phone and a faux-leather handbag into one box. Reviewers say it is cute and well made, and that the many pieces keep kids entertained for hours. The realistic-looking money and cards are a common highlight.
The watch is the mixed piece. Some buyers say it lights up and tells time, while others report that it does not work at all. Buyers who care most about the watch should read recent feedback before ordering.
What we like
- Many pieces in one set
- Realistic-looking money and cards
- Cute, well-made handbag
Keep in mind
- Watch reportedly does not work for some buyers
Best for: Girls aged 3 to 8 who like to act out shopping and everyday errands.

Easiest for young hands#9 best seller
Giggle and Honey Unicorn Music Box
Giggle & Honey® Musical Unicorn Jewelry Box for Girls
This musical jewelry box has a dancing unicorn that plays a tune when opened. Reviewers call it a great first jewelry box, with a size that suits small hands and a music knob a 3-year-old can wind. The box is made of pine fiberboard and the listing says it meets CPSIA, ASTM and EN71 guidelines.
Buyers appreciate the storage, with one noting it fits mini earrings and other children's jewelry. The listing also says it arrives in ready-to-gift packaging, which helps it work for birthdays and holidays.
What we like
- Simple enough for a 3-year-old to wind
- Size suits kids' hands
- Holds mini earrings and small jewelry
Keep in mind
- Storage is best suited to small pieces
Best for: Girls aged 3 to 5 who want a first jewelry box with a musical unicorn.

Best value for the money#10 best seller
Kids Unicorn Makeup Kit
Kids Real Makeup Kit with Unicorn Purse Non Toxic Washable Make Up Set
This pink unicorn makeup kit comes with a matching bag and washable, paraben-free makeup. Reviewers say it is adorable, offers nice quality for the price and is easy to clean up. One buyer notes it is not over the top for toddlers to play with.
Size gets mixed feedback. Some find it perfect, while others say it is smaller than expected. Buyers with a bigger budget may want to compare it with larger sets.
What we like
- Good quality for the price
- Easy to wash off
- Fits toddlers' play well
Keep in mind
- Some say it is smaller than expected
Best for: Parents of 3 to 10-year-olds who want an affordable unicorn makeup gift.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Melissa and Doug ice cream counter really durable?
Several buyers say the counter is sturdy enough to withstand years of use. It is also described as a favorite holiday gift that holds toddlers' attention for hours.
Do the makeup kits wash off easily?
Yes. The unicorn kit is described as easy to clean with water and light soap, and the listing says it is paraben-free and non-toxic. Some buyers of the larger kit say it is smaller than they expected, so check the size before buying.
Will the VTech toolbox work reliably?
Opinions are split. Some buyers say the drill is hard for little hands to operate, and others say the toy does not function properly. The toy takes 2 AA batteries, and the listing recommends new batteries for regular use.
Does the purse set's watch work?
Reviews disagree. Some say the watch lights up and tells time, while others say it does not work at all. Buyers who want the watch to work should read recent feedback before ordering.
How we chose these
We started from the top 8 products on Amazon's Best Seller list for Dressing Up & Costumes (as of November 8, 2026) and wrote this What Reviewers Love guide, with AI assistance, from their product details and what customers say in their reviews. We haven't tested these products ourselves, and no product or position is paid for. Rankings and availability change, so check Amazon for the latest details.
The verdict
For most families, the Melissa and Doug ice cream counter is the strongest all-round pick, thanks to reviewers' praise for its durability and long play sessions. If your child is younger or you want a simpler first gift, the Giggle and Honey unicorn music box is the easiest to use. Read the mixed notes on size, build quality and functionality before you buy, because those are where buyers differ most.
Our top pick: Giggle and Honey Unicorn Music Box
Check today's price on Amazon