As an Amazon Associate, LookItAllUp earns from qualifying purchases.
This guide is for shoppers choosing a renewed smartwatch who want to know what owners actually report after unboxing. Across these eight best sellers, the most consistent praise is that units look like new, while battery life and durability are a gamble that varies from unit to unit. Our verdict: the Series 9 Renewed Premium gets the most consistently positive comments on condition and everyday function.
What reviewers keep praising
Like-new appearance
Buyers across nearly every listing say the watch looks new or never worn, with the Series 9 models, the Series 8 and the SE mentioned most often for their clean finish.
Easy pairing and setup
Owners of the Series 7 45mm, the SE and the Series 9 Premium say their watches pair quickly with an iPhone, although a few report pairing trouble on the same models.
Battery life is a gamble
The battery is the most common mixed point across all eight listings, with some owners reporting full capacity and others reporting watches that will not hold a charge.
Condition varies by unit
Reports on scratches and damage differ widely, especially for the Series 7 41mm, the Series 7 45mm and the Ultra, so checking the screen and case on arrival is worthwhile.
Our top picks
Its feedback on condition, performance and ease of use is the most consistently positive of the eight listings.
See it on AmazonBuyers say it stays connected longer than a Fitbit and feel it is well worth the money.
See it on AmazonIts titanium case and 100m water resistance give it the strongest build in this lineup, though band reports are mixed.
See it on Amazon
Best for a like-new look#1 best seller
Apple Watch Series 7 41mm Starlight
Apple Watch Series 7 (GPS, 41mm) Starlight Aluminum Case with Starlight Sport Band, Regular (Renewed)
Buyers often describe this Series 7 as looking never worn, which is the strongest recurring praise for this listing. The Always-On display is noted in the product details as having nearly 20 percent more screen area than the Series 6, so the extra room is easy to notice day to day.
The catch is consistency. Some reviewers received units in perfect condition, while others report damaged watches, and a number of owners say the battery will not hold a charge or the watch will not turn on at all. Durability reports are also divided, with a few units failing within a week and others lasting only around four months.
What we like
- Buyers say it looks never worn
- Larger Always-On display than the Series 6, per the product details
- Blood oxygen, ECG and heart rhythm notifications included
Keep in mind
- Condition reports range from perfect to damaged
- Some owners say the battery will not keep a charge
- A few units reportedly failed within weeks
Best for: Shoppers who want the look of a new Apple Watch and are prepared to test the battery and condition on arrival.
![Apple Watch Ultra [GPS + Cellular 49mm] Titanium Case with Midnight Ocean Band, One Size (Renewed)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/810JR81LIsL._AC_SL1500_.jpg)
Best for rugged outdoor use#2 best seller
Apple Watch Ultra 49mm Titanium
Apple Watch Ultra [GPS + Cellular 49mm] Titanium Case with Midnight Ocean Band, One Size (Renewed)
The Ultra is the most purpose-built model here, with a 49mm corrosion-resistant titanium case, 100m water resistance and a brighter display that buyers say is easy to read in direct sunlight. Several reviewers describe it as being in brand-new condition and feel it is worth the price.
Reports on the basics are mixed. Some owners say the battery lasts and the watch works well, while others say it will not power on or drains quickly. The band is another point of disagreement, with some saying it holds up in harsh conditions and others reporting a band that broke within a week.
What we like
- Buyers describe it as brand new and well designed
- Titanium case and 100m water resistance per the product details
- Display reportedly easy to read in direct sunlight
Keep in mind
- Battery and power-on reports are split
- Some owners say the band broke within a week
- Scratch reports vary, with some units showing visible marks
Best for: Endurance athletes and outdoor users who want a rugged case and are willing to check battery and band quality early.
![Apple Watch Series 8 [GPS, 41mm] - Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band, M/L (Renewed)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51RjAAdhSUL._AC_SL1200_.jpg)
Best for crash and fall alerts#3 best seller
Apple Watch Series 8 41mm Midnight
Apple Watch Series 8 [GPS, 41mm] - Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band, M/L (Renewed)
Buyers who value safety features tend to focus on this Series 8, which includes Crash Detection, Fall Detection and Emergency SOS according to its product details. Many reviewers say the watch is in excellent condition and works well once set up.
The battery is the main complaint. A few owners report the watch will not turn on after an hour on the charger, and others say it needs daily charging. Opinions on value are also split, with some calling it a steal and others saying it is not worth the price. A handful of buyers also feel the size is wrong for their wrist.
What we like
- Crash Detection, Fall Detection and Emergency SOS are included
- Buyers describe the condition as excellent
- Water resistance rated WR50 in the product details
Keep in mind
- Several owners say the battery needs daily charging
- Some report it will not turn on after charging
- A few buyers say the size does not suit them
Best for: Anyone who wants strong safety features and is comfortable checking the battery and fit before settling in.
![Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 (2025) 44mm Bluetooth Smartwatch, Cushion Design, Fitness Tracker, Sleep Coaching, Running Coach, Energy Score, Heart Rate Tracking, Graphite [US Version] (Renewed)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/616KEp7qQvL._AC_SL1500_.jpg)
Best for sleep and running coaching#4 best seller
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 44mm
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 (2025) 44mm Bluetooth Smartwatch, Cushion Design, Fitness Tracker, Sleep Coaching, Running Coach, Energy Score, Heart Rate Tracking, Graphite [US Version] (Renewed)
This Galaxy Watch 8 is the most surprising pick for many buyers. Reviewers say it is well worth the money, looks like new, and stays connected longer than a Fitbit. The product details highlight Sleep Coaching, a Running Coach that gives real-time feedback and a lighter, thinner design.
Battery reports are the big question. Some owners say it lasts two to two and a half days, while others say it only lasts about five hours. Several customers also say they did not receive the original Samsung charger, so it is worth checking what is in the box.
What we like
- Buyers say it stays connected longer than a Fitbit
- Sleep Coaching and Running Coach included
- Lighter, thinner design per the product details
Keep in mind
- Battery life reports range from days to hours
- Several buyers did not get the original charger
- Durability reports are mixed
Best for: Runners and sleep-focused users who want a lightweight watch and do not mind a non-original charger.

Best for a larger display#5 best seller
Apple Watch Series 7 45mm Midnight
Apple Watch Series 7 (GPS, 45mm) Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band (Renewed)
The 45mm Series 7 has the largest screen in this lineup of Series 7 listings, with thinner borders that give more room for apps and notifications. Buyers say it appears like new and is a good buy for the money, and many say it pairs with their phone quickly.
The weak spots are condition and battery. Reviewers report mixed condition, with some saying it is not in excellent shape. Some owners report poor battery health, and a few note scratches on the face and pairing problems.
What we like
- Expanded Always-On display with thinner borders
- Buyers say it looks like new
- Many report quick pairing with their phone
Keep in mind
- Condition reports are mixed
- Some owners report poor battery health
- Several mention scratches on the face
Best for: Shoppers who want the largest screen in the Series 7 range and are happy to inspect the face and battery when it arrives.

Best for everyday iPhone fitness#6 best seller
Apple Watch SE 2nd Gen 40mm
Apple Watch SE (2nd Gen) (GPS, 40mm) - Starlight Aluminum Case with Starlight Sport Band, M/L (Renewed)
The SE is a simpler Apple option, with Crash Detection, irregular rhythm and high or low heart rate notifications, and 50m water resistance listed in its details. Buyers say it pairs seamlessly with iPhones and looks as good as new, and several describe the condition as indistinguishable from a brand new unit.
Durability and battery reports are mixed. Some owners say the battery reads full, while others say it will not hold a charge. A few report the watch lasting only 15 to 20 minutes, so testing the battery early is worth doing.
What we like
- Buyers say it pairs seamlessly with iPhones
- Condition described as indistinguishable from new
- Crash Detection and 50m water resistance included
Keep in mind
- Battery reports range from full to not holding charge
- A few owners report very short run time
- Durability feedback is split
Best for: iPhone owners who want core health and safety features in a 40mm watch and will check the battery promptly.
![Apple Watch Series 9 [GPS, 45mm] - Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band, M/L (Renewed Premium)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61HKwH5timL._AC_SL1500_.jpg)
Best for temperature and mood tracking#7 best seller
Apple Watch Series 9 45mm Premium
Apple Watch Series 9 [GPS, 45mm] - Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band, M/L (Renewed Premium)
Of the eight listings, this Series 9 Renewed Premium draws the most consistently positive feedback on condition and function. Buyers say it is in great condition and performs like new, and they find it easy to use. Some report battery health above 85 percent and no scratches.
It is not flawless. Some owners say it takes more than two hours to charge, others say the case is heavily scratched, and a few could not pair it with their iPhone. Its product details highlight temperature sensing for cycle tracking and a state of mind feature, which suit users who want more health data.
What we like
- Buyers say it performs like brand new
- Some report battery health above 85 percent
- Temperature sensing and state of mind tracking included
Keep in mind
- Some owners say charging takes over two hours
- A few report heavy scratches
- Some buyers had iPhone pairing trouble
Best for: Shoppers who want the most consistently praised Series 9 and want temperature and mood tracking.
![Apple Watch Series 9 [GPS 45mm] Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band M/L (Renewed)](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71aXGgNCE9L._AC_SL1500_.jpg)
Best for a flawless-looking Series 9#8 best seller
Apple Watch Series 9 45mm Midnight
Apple Watch Series 9 [GPS 45mm] Midnight Aluminum Case with Midnight Sport Band M/L (Renewed)
This Series 9 gets some of the warmest comments on appearance, with buyers describing it as flawless and like new in excellent condition. Many say it functions well and offers good value for the money. The product details also mention a carbon-neutral aluminum case and the latest Sport Loop.
The battery and scratch resistance are the points to check. Some owners say it holds full capacity, while others say it will not hold a charge. Scratch reports are split, with some noting no marks and others reporting issues.
What we like
- Buyers describe the appearance as flawless
- Many say it works well and offers good value
- Carbon-neutral aluminum case per the product details
Keep in mind
- Battery reports are split
- Some owners report scratches
- Battery capacity may vary between units
Best for: Buyers who want a clean-looking Series 9 at a good value and are ready to check the battery and screen on arrival.
Frequently asked questions
Will a renewed Apple Watch look like new?
Many buyers say these watches look like new or never worn, and the Series 9 and SE listings get especially warm comments on appearance. Some reviewers, however, received units with visible scratches or damage, so check the case and screen when the watch arrives.
Why do battery reports vary so much?
Reviewers describe very different experiences, from full capacity to watches that will not hold a charge or last only minutes. Because each renewed unit has its own history, battery health can differ from one watch to the next, so test it soon after delivery.
What if a renewed watch arrives faulty?
Renewed products are inspected and tested by Amazon-qualified suppliers and are eligible for replacement or refund under the Amazon Renewed Guarantee. Some owners say their units failed within weeks, so it is worth acting quickly if something is wrong.
Do I get the original charger with the Galaxy Watch 8?
Several customers say they did not receive the original Samsung charger, and some reported charger compatibility issues. Check the contents when your watch arrives and confirm the charger works before relying on it.
How we chose these
We started from the top 8 products on Amazon's Best Seller list for Renewed Smartwatches (as of November 8, 2026) and wrote this What Reviewers Love guide, with AI assistance, from their product details and what customers say in their reviews. We haven't tested these products ourselves, and no product or position is paid for. Rankings and availability change, so check Amazon for the latest details.
The verdict
If you want one renewed smartwatch to shortlist, the Series 9 Renewed Premium is the most consistently praised option, with buyers reporting strong condition and easy use. Whichever you choose, the reviews make one thing clear: check the battery, screen and pairing as soon as the watch arrives, since those are where experiences differ most.
Our top pick: Apple Watch Series 9 45mm Premium
Check today's price on Amazon