As an Amazon Associate, LookItAllUp earns from qualifying purchases.
If you want yarn that customers keep recommending, start with Caron All Day cotton, which reviewers describe as soft, easy to crochet with and softer after washing. Across these ten best sellers, colour range and value earn the most praise, while splitting, knots and shorter-than-advertised skeins are the complaints that recur.
Our top picks
It draws the most consistent praise for softness and washability, and the summary lists no recurring complaint.
See it on AmazonBuyers call it good value and say it suits beginners, though some find it stiff.
See it on AmazonReviewers highlight its softness for baby items and its dye-lot-free colours.
See it on AmazonCompare the picks
| Product | Reviewers love | Common complaint | Best for | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colour range and value | Rough feel, splitting | Afghans and everyday crochet | View | |
| Colours, value, beginner-friendly | Stiff, can come apart | Beginners and amigurumi | View | |
| Velvety softness, gorgeous colours | Falls apart, short yardage | Finger crochet and chunky throws | View | |
| Vibrant colours, easy crocheting | Splits, knots in some skeins | Budget multi-colour projects | View | |
| Appearance and chunky blankets | Yardage 5-6 yards short | Chunky tie-dye blankets | View | |
| Quality, easy work, blanket look | Thin spots, smaller than expected | Blankets and slippers | View | |
| Colours, large skeins | Splits, knots reported | Big throws and garments | View | |
| Softens with washing, easy crochet | No recurring complaint in summary | Dishcloths and wearables | View | |
| Baby items, looks as pictured | Too thin, splits on small hooks | Baby items with fine hooks | View | |
| Softness, dye-free colours | Splits easily | Baby projects and garments | View |
- Reviewers love
- Colour range and value
- Common complaint
- Rough feel, splitting
- Best for
- Afghans and everyday crochet
- Reviewers love
- Colours, value, beginner-friendly
- Common complaint
- Stiff, can come apart
- Best for
- Beginners and amigurumi
- Reviewers love
- Velvety softness, gorgeous colours
- Common complaint
- Falls apart, short yardage
- Best for
- Finger crochet and chunky throws
- Reviewers love
- Vibrant colours, easy crocheting
- Common complaint
- Splits, knots in some skeins
- Best for
- Budget multi-colour projects
- Reviewers love
- Appearance and chunky blankets
- Common complaint
- Yardage 5-6 yards short
- Best for
- Chunky tie-dye blankets
- Reviewers love
- Quality, easy work, blanket look
- Common complaint
- Thin spots, smaller than expected
- Best for
- Blankets and slippers
- Reviewers love
- Colours, large skeins
- Common complaint
- Splits, knots reported
- Best for
- Big throws and garments
- Reviewers love
- Softens with washing, easy crochet
- Common complaint
- No recurring complaint in summary
- Best for
- Dishcloths and wearables
- Reviewers love
- Baby items, looks as pictured
- Common complaint
- Too thin, splits on small hooks
- Best for
- Baby items with fine hooks
- Reviewers love
- Softness, dye-free colours
- Common complaint
- Splits easily
- Best for
- Baby projects and garments

Best for afghans on a budget#1 best seller
RED HEART Super Saver, Cafe Latte
RED HEART Super Saver Yarn, Cafe Latte
Reviewers love the cafe latte colour and say the variegated shades look good on finished pieces. Many also note that it is excellent value and suits afghans and everyday crochet well.
Opinions on feel and knots are divided. Some say it is surprisingly soft and durable, while others describe it as rough and prone to splitting. Knot reports also vary between skeins.
What we like
- Colour praised, including how variations look finished
- Excellent value, according to buyers
- Versatile for crochet, especially afghans
Keep in mind
- Some find it rough to the touch
- Splitting is reported by some buyers
- Knots are reported in some skeins
Best for: Crocheters making afghans who want a classic colour and do not mind some roughness.

Best value for beginners#2 best seller
Red Heart Super Saver, White, Single
Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting, White, Single
Buyers appreciate the range of colourways, from pastels and ombres to solids, and say the yarn offers good value for money. Many describe it as a great fit for beginners trying crochet, knitting or amigurumi.
The feedback on feel is split. Some find it soft and strong, while others say it is stiff and can come apart, so handle it carefully on projects that see heavy wear.
What we like
- Wide colourway choice, including ombre and speckled
- Described as good value for money
- Easy to work with, according to beginners
Keep in mind
- Some reviewers call it stiff
- Others report it can come apart
- Knot counts vary between skeins
Best for: Beginners and amigurumi makers who want an affordable, colourful worsted yarn.

Softest pick for finger crochet#3 best seller
Cozyful Chunky Yarn, Cream
Cozyful Chunky Yarn for Hand Knitting - #10 Chunky Chenille Yarn, Jumbo Big Thick Chunky Yarns for Crocheting, Super Bulky Chunky Knit Blanket Yarns, 8 Skein (22 yds 8 oz Each Skein), Cream
Reviewers say this chenille yarn is incredibly soft, with a velvety feel, and they praise its gorgeous colours. Finger crocheters find it especially easy to handle, and one buyer mentions it works for hand knitting too.
The warning here is durability and length. Some buyers say it falls apart easily and is thin in places, while several report skeins shorter than the advertised 25 yards.
What we like
- Incredibly soft, velvety texture
- Easy to handle for finger crochet
- Gorgeous colours, according to buyers
Keep in mind
- Some say it falls apart easily
- Several skeins reported short of advertised yardage
- Some find it thin in places
Best for: Finger crocheters and chunky throw makers who prioritise softness and can check yardage.

Best multipack for everyday projects#4 best seller
RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack, Aran
RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn, ARAN 3 Pack
Buyers describe this three-pack as a go-to choice, citing vibrant colours and good value for the price. Crocheters in particular say it is incredibly easy to work with.
Durability is the main debate. Some say it does not fall apart easily, while others say it splits badly. Knot reports are mixed too, with some buyers noticing none and others finding several in each skein.
What we like
- Vibrant colours, according to buyers
- Good value across the three-pack
- Easy to crochet with
Keep in mind
- Some report it splits badly
- Knot counts vary between skeins
Best for: Crocheters who want a multipack of bright colours for regular projects.

Best look for chunky blankets#5 best seller
Cozyful Chunky Tie Dye Yarn
Cozyful Chunky Yarn for Hand Knitting - #10 Chunky Chenille Blanket Yarn, Jumbo Big Thick Chunky Yarns for Crocheting, Tie Dye Bulky Knit Yarns, 8 Skein (20 yds 8 oz Each Skein), Cream&Sage&Grey&Khaki
Buyers are impressed by the thickness, quality and appearance of this tie-dye chenille, and many say it makes great chunky blankets. The colours are described as nice and it is easy to work with.
Yardage is the standout complaint. Reviewers report skeins about 5 to 6 yards shorter than advertised, and fraying is mixed in with comments that it holds up well.
What we like
- Attractive tie-dye appearance
- Thick and easy to work with, per buyers
- Praised for chunky blankets
Keep in mind
- Reviewers report 5 to 6 yards less than advertised
- Fraying is mentioned by some buyers
Best for: Blanket makers who love the look and will weigh skeins before starting.

Best for blankets and slippers#6 best seller
Bernat Blanket Super Bulky, Almond
Bernat Blanket Super Bulky Polyester Yarn - 2 Pack of 300g/10.5oz #6 Chunky Chenille Heavy Weight Yarn for Knitting and Crocheting, Amigurumi, Thick Blankets (Almond, 220 Yards 2-Pack)
Customers love the quality of this super bulky chenille and find it easy to work with, especially for blankets and slippers. One buyer says the colour looks like the aurora borealis.
Size and thickness are mixed. Some like the bulk for chunky projects, while others say it is thin in places or smaller than they expected. Knot counts also vary between skeins.
What we like
- Quality praised by many buyers
- Easy to work with for blankets and slippers
- Striking colour, per one buyer
Keep in mind
- Some find it thin in places
- Some say skeins are smaller than expected
- Knot counts vary
Best for: Blanket and slipper makers who want a bulky chenille and will check the skein size.

Best jumbo skein for big projects#7 best seller
RED HEART Super Saver Jumbo, Black
RED HEART E302C.0312 Super Saver Jumbo Yarn, Black
Reviewers love the colours and find the jumbo skein makes larger projects easier to finish. They say it works for beginners and experienced crafters alike, and one buyer mentions it suits clothes, hats, blankets and dolls.
Durability and knots are the sore spots. Some say it does not fall apart or tangle, while others say it splits easily and comes with knots.
What we like
- Colours praised by buyers
- Large skein helps bigger projects
- Easy to work with for all skill levels
Keep in mind
- Some report it splits easily
- Knots are reported in some skeins
Best for: Makers working on big throws or garments who want fewer skein joins.

Best for dishcloths and kitchen crafts#8 best seller
Caron All Day Cotton Yarn, 3-Pack
Caron All Day Cotton Yarn for Crocheting, Cream, 3-Pack
Reviewers call this their favourite cotton to work with. They say it feels soft yet strong and becomes softer with each wash, which suits dishcloths and kitchen projects that get laundered often.
Buyers also point to a good spread of colours, including a deep sea blue that one reviewer singled out, and say it is easy to handle for crochet wearables.
What we like
- Softens with washing, according to reviewers
- Easy to work with for crochet wearables
- Good spread of colours to choose from
Keep in mind
- Reviewers did not raise a recurring complaint in the summary
Best for: Crocheters making dishcloths, bags and summer wearables who want a washable cotton.

Best for baby items#9 best seller
Keche Baby Cotton, Black
Keche Baby Cotton, 60% Cotton 40% Acrylic Yarn, Soft Cotton Yarn for Crochet and Knitting, Amigurumi Yarn 1 Skein/Ball 1.76 Oz (50g) / 180 Yrds (165m) - Black
Buyers find this cotton-acrylic blend suitable for baby items and small projects, and say it looks just as pictured. They report it works well for their projects and is easy to handle.
The thickness debate is the main issue. Some call it perfectly thin and smooth, while others say it is too thin and splits, particularly on a 1.75mm hook. Value for money also divides buyers.
What we like
- Suits baby items and small projects
- Looks as pictured, per buyers
- Easy to work with
Keep in mind
- Some find it too thin
- Splits, especially on a 1.75mm hook
- Value for money is divisive
Best for: Crafters making small baby items who will use a hook that suits the thin yarn.

Best for baby projects#10 best seller
Caron Simply Soft 3-Pack, White
Caron Simply Soft 3-Pack Yarn, 3oz, Gauge 4 Medium Worsted, 100% Acrylic -White - Machine Wash & Dry
Reviewers say this acrylic is especially soft for baby projects and praise the wide range of colours, which come without dye lots. Knitters using circular machines find it easy to work with, and buyers see good value across the three balls.
Splitting is the main complaint. Some say it holds up well to heavy use, while others say it splits easily.
What we like
- Especially soft for baby projects
- Wide colour range without dye lots
- Easy to work with on circular machines
Keep in mind
- Some report it splits easily
Best for: Knitters making baby garments and throws who want soft, machine-washable acrylic.
How we chose these
We started from the top 10 products on Amazon's Best Seller list for Yarn (as of November 8, 2026) and wrote this What Reviewers Love guide, with AI assistance, from their product details and what customers say in their reviews. We haven't tested these products ourselves, and no product or position is paid for. Rankings and availability change, so check Amazon for the latest details.
The verdict
Caron All Day Cotton Yarn is the overall top pick. Reviewers describe it as soft, easy to crochet and softer after washing, and the summary raises no recurring complaint. If you want a bargain for beginners, Red Heart Super Saver is the sensible choice, and if you are making chunky blankets, weigh your skeins first, because yardage shortfalls come up often.
Our top pick: Caron All Day Cotton Yarn, 3-Pack
Check today's price on Amazon